Was Cleopatra a Medieval Queen?

It appears, today we have this image of Cleopatra, the ancient Egyptian queen, ingrained in our minds. In my previous opinion Cleopatra was a strikingly beautiful woman, who looked what an ancient Egyptian woman was supposed to look like. And of course, Cleopatra related movies contributed to this impression, which at this very moment appears to be highly questionable.

anthony_cleopatra-1.jpg

cleopatra_3_1-1.jpg

While going over some of the ancient Roman stuff, I started seeing paintings dated with 15th, 16th, 17th and 18th centuries where Cleopatra looked nothing like what we are used to today. For me those early images mean that some 500 years ago, there was a totally different understanding of certain events and historical circumstances. Below are a few examples of those paintings and etchings.

15th century art
Antony_and_Cleopatra_31.jpg

Woodcut_illustration_of_Cleopatra_and_Mark_Antony_-_Penn_Provenance_Project-11.jpg


16th century art
Cleopatra-77.jpg


17th century art
Cleopatra-17-1.jpg

cleopatra-17-2.jpg

Cleopatra and the Asp_3.jpg


18th century art
cleo-18-1.jpg

Giovanni_Battista_Tiepolo_The Banquet of Cleopatra.jpg


Here we run into the 19th century, and Cleopatra, all over sudden, starts gaining her contemporary appearance. I'm not going to link the images to the source. You can easily google the 19th century Cleopatra paintings.

cabanel_cleopatra_poison.jpg

brigdman_cleopatra_philae.jpg Cleopatra_holds_the_dead_Antony.jpg gerome_cleopatra_caesar.jpg rixens_death_cleopatra.jpg The_Death_of_Cleopatra.jpg

* * * And there you go. In the 21st century we end up with her * * *

Cleopatra: 21st century

21_century_cleopatra.jpg


Compare to: 15th century Cleo
Mark Antony and Cleopatra
Antony_and_Cleopatra_3.jpg


Of course, we could go the beaten path of our dogmatic historians. They would most likely say that in the 15th century people only had texts, and were unable to fully understand the cultural specifics of the ancient Egyptians. Or, we could come up with a few additional explanations aimed at burying the issue within some pseudo-scientific gibberish language.

KD summary: I keep on looking at this image (above) of Mark Antony and Cleopatra, thinking that we got duped one more time. We have to be delusional to think that in 2018 we know better than people knew in 1403. And by the looks of it, those artists had a very different idea of what Cleopatra looked like some 600 years ago.

Cleopatra-and-Mark-Anthony.jpg

Could it be that "antiquity" is not something which took place 2000 years ago, but rather was a time frame fairly contemporary to some of the above paintings and etchings? If we consider the possibility of Pompeii getting buried in 1631, and this bizarre 15th century emergence of the ancient statues... who's there to say (besides the officials) that Cleopatra was not some 14th century queen?
 

Similar articles

Top