Did Monomotapa-city become South African Pretoria-city?

KorbenDallas

Negotiator
Messages
3,840
Reactions
14,527
I was always wondering why a city in South Africa would be named Pretoria. The interest is somewhat self-explanatory.
  • Praetor was a title granted by the government of Ancient Rome to men acting in one of two official capacities: the commander of an army; or, an elected magistrate, assigned various duties.
praetor.jpg

Somehow, I thought there was a connection there. Well, I got schooled by the narrative, and the reason it is called Pretoria goes like this:
  • Pretoria was founded in 1855 by Marthinus Pretorius, a leader of the Voortrekkers, who named it after his father Andries Pretorius and chose a spot on the banks of the "Monkeys river" to be the new capital of the South African Republic. The elder Pretorius had become a national hero of the Voortrekkers after his victory over Dingane and the Zulus in the Battle of Blood River. The elder Pretorius also negotiated the Sand River Convention (1852), in which the UK acknowledged the independence of the Transvaal. It became the capital of the South African Republic (ZAR) on 1 May 1860.
Here are our heroes by the way. Marthinus Pretorius (1819 – 1901 ) is on the left, and his father Andries Pretorius (1798 – 1853 ) on the right.

Pretorius.jpg

Kind of discouraging it was, but a little bit of Andries Pretorius's bio allowed me to keep on going in my search.
  • Pretorius descended from the line of the earliest Dutch settlers in the Cape Colony. He belonged to the fifth generation of the progenitor, Johannes Pretorius son of Reverend Wessel Schulte of the Netherlands. Schulte in his time as a theology student at the University of Leiden changed his name to the Latin form and therefore became Wesselius Praetorius (later Pretorius).
To be honest, I kind of knew where to look, for the last name Pretorius did not sound Dutch to me. Sure enough, German origin last name Schulte was changed to Praetorius.
  • Schulte in his time as a theology student at the University of Leiden changed his name to the Latin form and therefore became Wesselius Praetorius (later Pretorius).
Today, Pretorius is a common Afrikaans surname:
  • Recorded in several forms (including Praetor, Praetorius, Pratorius, Pretorius, (German), and in English Preater, Preter and Pretor), Pretorius is a surname of Germanic origins, although the ultimate origin is the Roman word "praetor". This literally meant "leader", but was used in Imperial Rome to describe officials who led processions, as well as the Praetorian Guard, who provided the security for the Senate and the Imperial Roman family. Although apparently first recorded in England several centuries before Germany, which is probably because of lost medieval records, it is rare in England, although now found in some numbers in Austria, Switzerland and South Africa.
  • LOL, these "probably" and "apparently" will never cease to amaze me.
Next I went to see the meaning of the name Schulte:
  • The name Schulte comes from one of those ancient dukedoms, territories and states that would eventually form a part of present day Germany. At its birth in the Middle Ages, it was used to indicate someone who worked as a town-mayor derived from the medieval name "Schultheis" which has the same meaning.
A convenient last name to have, to say the least. In my opinion "town-mayor" sounds more like a title, rather than a last name. Yet it does check out. One way, or the other, there was my Ancient Roman connection. By the way:
lictors.jpg

In reality, the entire Johannesburg area presents the exact same interest, and once we get to the older maps you will understand why. As you can see, we have this nice little place called Centurion. I'm not sure when it received its name, but this infatuation with Ancient Rome is just bizarre.

Ancient Rome, for a second, was separated from this region of South Africa by 5,000 miles and 1,500 years. Why did they like it so much?
Pretoria is situated approximately 55 km (34 mi) north-northeast of Johannesburg in the northeast of South Africa, in a transitional belt between the plateau of the Highveld to the south and the lower-lying Bushveld to the north. It lies at an altitude of about 1,339 m (4,393 ft) above sea level, in a warm, sheltered, fertile valley, surrounded by the hills of the Magaliesberg range.

pretoria_map.jpg


Architecture of Pretoria
This structure below is called the Union Buildings. Allegedly completed in 1913. The below two images are dated with 1920. I simply do not believe that what we are seeing was only 7 years old at the time the photographs were taken. Additionally, the entire construction story sounds rather interesting.

Union-Buildings-1920_1.jpg

The Union Buildings story goes like this:
  • In 1909 Herbert Baker was commissioned to design the Government Building of the Union of South Africa (which was formed on 31 May 1910) in Pretoria. Pretoria was to become the administrative centre for the new government. In November 1910 the cornerstone of the Union Building was laid.
  • Lord Selborne and H.C. Hull, a member of the first Union Cabinet, chose Meintjieskop as the site for Baker's design. The site was that of a disused quarry and the existing excavations were used to create the amphitheatre, which was set about with ornamental pools, fountains, sculptures, balustrades and trees.
  • The design consisted of two identical wings, joined by a semicircular colonnade forming the backdrop of the amphitheatre. The colonnade was terminated on either side by a tower. Each wing had a basement and three floors above ground. The interiors were created in the Cape Dutch style with carved teak fanlights, heavy doors, dark ceiling beams contrasting with white plaster walls and heavy wood furniture. Baker used indigenous materials as far as possible. The granite was quarried on site while Buiskop sandstone was used for the courtyards. Stinkwood and Rhodesian teak were used for timber and wood panelling. The roof tiles and quarry tiles for the floors were made in Vereeniging.
  • The cornerstone was laid in November 1910, shortly after the Union of South Africa – for which the buildings are named – was formed. Taking 1,265 workers over three years to build, the structure was completed in 1913 at a total cost of £1,310,640 for the building and £350,000 for the site.
  • Designed by Sir Herbert Baker in 1908, building began in 1909 and was completed in 1913. It took approximately 1265 artisans, workmen and labourers almost three years to construct, using 14 million bricks for the interior office walls, half a million cubic feet of freestone, 74 000 cubic yards of concrete, 40 000 bags of cement and 20 000 cubic feet of granite.
Union-Buildings-1920.jpg


Early Sketch
Early sketch of the Union Buildings.jpg

At the same time, we do have some construction, and near construction photos. Judge for yourself whether there is anything of importance there. Looks like the structure is being built, at the same time the quality of this scaffolding below looks strange.
union_buildings_007.jpg


union_buildings_003.jpgunion_buildings_001.jpgunion_buildings_002.jpg
union_buildings_009.jpgunion_buildings_008.jpgunion_buildings_004.jpgUnion Buildings Pretoria, during Construction.jpg
It's not so much the building itself, but what's beneath the building which makes me feel uneasy about it. It's like it was built on top of something else. The arches below the structure look like so many of the other ones we have seen before.



Then we have a whole group of buildings which make me question the photography invention time frame.


Palace of Justice
Palace-of-Justice-Pretoria.jpg

Palace of Justice, Pretoria - Wikipedia

Old Government Building
Raadsaal-1.jpg

Ou Raadsaal - Wikipedia + Inside

Pretoria Boys High School
Pretoria Boys High School.jpg

Pretoria Boys High School - Wikipedia


Church Square, 1899
pretoria_1899.jpg


Voortrekker Monument
Voortrekker Monument.jpg


Post Office
Post office.jpg

Anyways, there were, and still are tons of these buildings in Pretoria, and even more in Johannesburg.

Rare English map of Southern Africa, published by Jonas Moore in London. The map appeared in Moore's A New Geography. Many of the plates in the work were engraved by Herman Moll, who had moved to London in 1678 and had not yet begun publishing under his own name. These are among the earliest known maps engraved by Moll. Burden credits Moll's first map as being his work for William Berry, also in 1681.

1681
monomotapa.jpg

Source

1630
monomotapa_1.jpg

Source

1727
moll1.jpg

Some easy side by side map comparison will place our Pretoria, and Johannesburg right on the spot. The reason I think Pretoria better matches this City of Monomotapa is simple. Pretoria is the capital, so, naturally, a Ville Royale of sorts. Somehow, I think our founder, Mr. Pretoreus knew that.

Once you look for the current terrain features of the former rivers in the area, you will see how perfectly this MONO-city matches Pretoria/Johannesburg. There are multiple maps you can reference. Here is a link for your convenience:
pretoria_map_1_1.jpg

Then, as you can see, something happens prior to 1769, and the entire Empire of Monomotapa got moved to our contemporary Zimbabwe, and Mozambique.

What's interesting, as far as Mozambique goes (a bit off topic here) is this:
  • The Somali merchants from Mogadishu, the capital of the Ajuran Empire, established a colony in Mozambique to extract gold from the mines in Sofala.
  • In 1505 the Portuguese were granted permission to erect a factory and fortress at Sofala.
1572
City_of_Sofala,_1572.jpg

The former Monomotapa area became a desert populated by some savages. Whether the entire Empire of M. picked up, and moved North-West, or this is just the beginning of map re-adjustments to fit the narrative, I don't know. But the result of it, the contemporary historians are placing Monomotapa in Zimbabwe, which is incorrect.

Mono_3.jpg

Source

Wondering what happened there... could these "meteorite" craters have had something to do with this?

craters_africa_2.jpg

Saudi Arabia craters are not included in the image

Monomotapa, outlined by the green line, was a serious Empire. Well, at least it appears that way. A few cities they had as well.

Monomotapa_33.jpg

Source

Now, if you don't look for stuff, you can't be wrong. But looking at the older maps it's easy to see that back in the day there was a region, and a Royal City (Ville Royale) called MONOMOTAPA. Here is some narrative:
  • In old maps of south-east Africa, derived originally from Portuguese and from Dutch sources, an extensive region on the Cuama or Zambezi and to the south of it is styled regnum monomotapae.The precise character of the kingdom or empire to which allusion is made has been the subject of much discussion, and some modern historians have gone so far as to relegate the monomotapa to the realm of myth. But such scepticism is unjustifiable in view of the perfect unanimity with which, in spite of variations of detail, all Portuguese writers from the beginning of the 16th century onwards reiterated the assertion that there was a powerful rule known far and wide by that title.
  • The word "monomotapa " is of Bantu origin and has been variously interpreted. Father J. Torrend, Comparative Grammar of the South African Bantu Languages (p. Ioi) renders it " Lord of the water-elephants," and remarks that the hippopotamus is even to the present day a sacred animal among the Karanga. The earliest recorded bearer .of the name is Mokomba Menamotapam, mentioned by Diogo de Alcacova in 1506 as father of the Kwesarimgo Menamotapam who ruled at that date over Vealanga, a large kingdom that included Sofala. His capital was called Zumubany, an obvious corruption of the term " Zimbabwe," regularly used to describe the residence of any important chief. The title is still found during the 18th century, but had probably become extinct by the beginning of the 19th if not earlier. Possibly its use was not confined to a single tribal section, occurring as it does in conjunction with the distinct dynastic names of Mokomba and Mambo, but the Karanga is the only tribe to which the Portuguese chroniclers attribute it. The latter, indeed, not only refer to the territory and the people of the monomotapa as " Mocaranga " (i.e. of the Karanga tribe), but explicitly assert that the " emperor " himself was a " Mocaranga." Consequently, he must have been a negro, and the Dominican who records the baptism of Dom Filippe by a friar of the order in the middle of the 17th century actually states that this " powerful king " was a black man (`; corn as carnes pretas "). This alone would be sufficient to controvert the baseless assumption that there existed in southern Rhodesia a ruling caste of different racial origin from the general Bantu population. The events following on the murder of the Jesuit father Dom Gongalo da Silveira (cf. Lusiads X. 93) sufficiently demonstrate that the monomotapa, though susceptible to the persuasion of foreigners, was an independent potentate in the 16th century. The state and ceremony of his court, the number of his wives, and the order and organization of his officials, are described by several of the chroniclers.
  • It is difficult to arrive at an estimate of the extent of territory over which this great negro chief exercised direct or indirect control. The most extravagant theory is naturally that which was expressed by the Portuguese advocates in connexion with the dispute as to the ownership of Delagoa Bay. The crown of Portugal based its case against England on the cession of territory contained in a well-known treaty with the monomotapa (1629), and stated that this monarch's dominions then extended nearly to the Cape of Good Hope. A more moderate and usual view is given by Diego de Couto, who in 1616 speaks of " a dominion over all Kaffraria from the Cabo das Correntes to the great river Zambezi." Several 17th-century writers extend the " empire " to the north of the Zambezi, Bocarro giving it in all " a circumference of more than three hundred leagues." It was " divided among petty kings and other lords with fewer vassals who are called inkosis or fumes." According to these authors, however, including Dos Santos, the paramountcy of the monomotapa was impaired in the 17th century by a series of rebellions. His zimbabwe, wherever it may have been in earlier days, was now;fixed near the Portuguese fort of Masapa, only a short distance south of the Zambezi. A Portuguese garrison was maintained in it, and the monarch himself from the year 1607 onwards was little more than a puppet who was generally baptized by the Dominicans with a Portuguese name.
Now, I do not know why our contemporary historians think that the "Great Negro Chief" was supposed to be black. May be because we had this image published between 1865-1880.

king_monomotapa.jpg

Meanwhile, some time around 1522 this Monomotapa region was ruled by this caucasian looking King - Hengi Zedaici. The linked books are in French. So, whoever wants to volunteer to translate, thank you very much.

Hengi_1.jpg


king_old.jpg

Source
kd_separator.jpg

KD: Back to the Pretorius family. Could they be sent to where Monomotapa-city once stood to fulfill their "ancient" Roman duties of Praetors, while simultaneously fishing for the recently buried reaches of the Ville Royalle?

I do think the world was global, and stuff was more or less similar all over. Same civilization was building similar structures relatively at the same time, using the similar technology. In some places we attribute the structures to the Ancient Rome, and Greece. In other places our historical narrative placed the structures much closer to today's date. I think South Africa, including Pretoria/Johannesburg could be one of such places.

Will take a little break from this for right now. Would be nice if someone did some research into the 16th -17th century Portuguese Maps, As far as this area goes. Sounds like there are quite a few reasons to enjoy that area, with gold being just one of those. The below 1630 Louis Texeira map I did not find, by the way.

monomotapa_1_gold.jpg
 

Mabzynn

Well-known member
Messages
113
Reactions
399
"Empires De Bororos"

The Bororo are indigenous people of Brazil, living in the state of Mato Grosso. They also extended into Bolivia and the Brazilian state of Goiás. The Western Bororo live around the Jauru and Cabaçal rivers. The Eastern Bororo live in the region of the São Lourenço, Garças, and Vermelho Rivers.

or...

Wodaabe peoples are actually a subgroup of the larger Fulbe-speaking Fulani. They prefer to call themselves Bororo. Fulani are a nomadic people who have been influential in regional politics, economics, and histories throughout western Africa for over a thousand years. Wodaabe live in northern Nigeria and played a significant role in furthering Fulani domination in the area. The height of the Fulani empire was between the early 1800s and early 1900s. This power was consolidated under Usman dan Fodio and was centered in northern Nigeria. Dan Fodio was a devout Muslim who used religious fervor to ignite his troops to undertake a series of holy wars. Following the early success of Islamic warriors, non-Islamic Fulani joined ranks with their fellows to form an extensive and powerful empire.

Map of the Mozambique Channel of the West Coast of Madagascar Island and the Monomotapa States] / hand manuscript of Danville
22061

This might not be a great translation - "The height of Mombaca, without knowing precisely how far it extends. pp. Jesuits wanted to go through this lake to Abissinia. its width is not comparable to its length. It encloses a very large quantity of islands, which are deserted. It abounds in fish, and on its banks are found millet, flesh, and plumper. the winds of the setting regent on this lake in March and April, as on the coast of Mocambique it is claimed that it has a bottom of eight or ten fathoms this lake is probably that which one speaks under the name of Zambre. FROM MASSI"

Lower Aethiopia, which includes the kingdoms of Congo, Coste, and Cafre country, Monomotapa empire, and Monoemugi, the coast since Cape Negre is partly drawn from Samuel Blommaert, and beyond that with the island of Madagascar, Sanuto , inside the country, others / by N. Sanson d'Abbeville (1655)
Lower Aethiopia.png

Basse Aethiopie, qui comprend les royaumes de Congo, coste, et pays des Cafres, empire du Monomotapa, et Monoemugi, la coste depuis le cap Negre est tirée en partie de Samuel Blommaert, et en dela avecq l'isle de Madagascar, de Sanuto, le dedans du pays, d'autres / par N. Sanson d'Abbeville | Gallica

22063

Looks like j655 to me.
22064


A draught of the south part of Africa from cape Bona Esperance to Delagoa (1700-1799)
22065

A draught of the south part of Africa from cape Bona Esperance to Delagoa | Gallica


Western Ethiopia 1732
22080

L'Ethiopie occidentale / par le Sr d'Anville, 1732 | Gallica

Aethiopia inferior - Joan Blaeu - 1663
download (2).png

Aethiopia inferior, vel exterior, partes magis septentrionales, quae hic desiderantur, vide in tabula Aethiopiae superioris / [Joan Blaeu] | Gallica
Here's the text (translated from Latin bear with me): "Monomotapa, or, as others call it, Bonomotapoa, unto Cæsar noting that, following the name of the kingdom of the king of the application used, so that they may be one, or otherwise than in the other kingdoms of the use to be. The most fair, and the result of the increase held. has with its rivers, and the forests, filled with elephants. The inhabitants are black and hairy, combative, general, nimble. when they act in a number of gods or religion is not Adola is being pulled apart, the only true worship a god whom his Mozima they call it.

At that time, the king of the Portuguese ruled over the ten Sebastian, the Christian religion he embraced the emperor Monomotapensis was, he accepted the baptism, but they are not the same that shall faint, Gonzalo de Cordoba, from the forest, he pretended to soft them, gave them a long time. This extends to the head of the kingdom still hopeful. The city is the primary Monomotapa, located at the ideas of the river near the holy spirit seat. is subject to this the kingdom, appointed station in the kingdom, and whom he had a rich man the mines. This magnificent home is amazing, Creed, square shape and great stones erected."

Special map of the coast of Africa which includes the country of Cafres (shown on the coast of all maps with Monomotapa). (1700)
download (1).png

Carte particulière des costes de l'Afrique qui comprend le pays des Cafres ... | Gallica

Showing star forts scattered about
22067


22068


22069


Look like they would be decent for treasure hunting as well
22070

Lost ship
22079

Crown of Moma
22071

Crown of S. Antonio and here's where it gets weird... I can't find what Bayxo means in Portuguese and it appears on the above island as well. It could just be a bay or shallow of some sort. However it could also be derived from the root for: baixão / bai.xão. 1 MÚS kind of bassoon, contra-bassoon (wind instrument). If anyone knows what this means and I'm way off here just let me know... Could this be the resting places of Lictor's fascists?

I should mention this is what the Biblioteca Nacional de Brasil has cataloged under the search for Bayxo (Baixo) - from the temple of Karnak:
22083

Here's some text from the book the Society of Jesus wrote on Hengi Zedaici, again rough translation:

"Remain the two associated names Hengi Zedaici, who have ruffled all the cartographers who came after Waltzemuller. On the Ptolomee map of Ruscelli, Hengi has become a Heuggi city. Gerard Mercator has two cities Heuggi or Henggi and Zedaia, which his Flemish and Dutch continuators have blindly transcribed. it is clear that the names in question, like many others on the map of 1522, are altered products; but it is not too difficult to extract the original names, by consulting the Italian and Portuguese relations of the beginning of the sixteenth century. Hengi must represent the Zinghi or Zangui, that is, the native blacks of eastern Nfrica south of ecuador; this noom, which is found, not only at the historian Barros (1550), but already in a relation of the Florentine traveler Andre Corsali comes from Persians and Arabs; it still exists today in the denomination of Zanguebar, country of Zang or Zandj, that had written Xengibar. Hengi is therefore for Zengi and designates the black population of central Africa.

Zedaici must also be a name of people; we believe to discover the explanation in a curious passage of Barros. The celebrated Portuguese historian relates an Arab tradition, noted, he says, in a chronicle of the kings of Quiloa, according to which the first foreigners who arrived in this part of Africa, attracted by. the smell of gold. They were Hannis of Arabia, whom the Arabs of Quiloa called Emozaydy, and the cause of their banishment was that they followed the doctrine of an Arab called Zayd, nephew of Hocem (hocein), son of son-in-law of Mahomet. This zayd had some opinions contrary to the Koran, and all who followed his doctrine, the Arabs call them Emozaydy, which means Zayd's subjects, and regard them as heretics. Orthodox Arabs later came to settle on this coast, the Emozaydy were obliged to retreat before them and to sink into the interior of the continent, where they mingled with the blacks. That's what Barros says. The heretical Arabs of which he speaks are, of course, the Shiites of Yemen, which Muslim historians, for example Ibn Kahldoun, call Zeidiya, is the Zeidites or followers of Zeid. It is this name which seems to us to be the origin of Zedaici of Hylacomylus."

The source the author sites - This relationship which consists of two letters written in 1515 and 1517 to Julient and Laurent de Medicis, Corsali describes the voyage he made on Portuguese ships, from Lisbon to India, and India to the coast, the Red Sea where he died in 1516.

Études

 
Last edited:

Top